Assessing a broken home appliance for repair. Learn when to fix or replace your refrigerator, stove, or dishwasher with expert tips from SecondShop.

Appliance Not Working? How to Assess Repairs vs. Replacements

Buying a new appliance is a significant investment, and it can be frustrating when it stops working. Before rushing to repair or replace it, understanding the cost factors, warranties, and lifespan of the appliance can help you make a smart financial decision.

TL;DR (When to Repair vs. Replace)

Appliance Avg. Lifespan Repair If… Replace If…
Refrigerator 10-15 years Under $500 repair Over 10 years old & costly repairs
Oven/Stove 13-15 years Minor electrical issue Heating elements failing frequently
Dishwasher 7-12 years Simple part replacement Leaks, motor failure
Washing Machine 8-12 years Pump or belt issue Drum failure or frequent leaks
Dryer 10-13 years Vent cleaning, minor fixes Not heating properly

Step 1: Identify the Issue

Before considering repairs or replacement, first diagnose the problem:

  • Power Check – Ensure the appliance is plugged in and the circuit breaker isn't tripped.
  • Basic Troubleshooting – Check for clogged filters, blocked vents, or tripped safety features.
  • Error Codes – Some appliances display error codes that can guide you to the issue.
  • Manufacturer Support – Many brands like Samsung appliances, LG appliances, and Bosch appliances provide online troubleshooting guides.

If the issue is minor, a simple fix might be all you need. If not, it’s time to evaluate repair costs.

Comparing an old, broken refrigerator with a brand-new model. Find out when to repair or replace your home appliances with SecondShop’s expert guide.

Step 2: Check the Warranty

Many new appliances come with a one-year warranty, covering defects and malfunctions. Before paying for repairs, check if your appliance is still under warranty:

  • Manufacturer Warranty – Most appliances have at least a one-year manufacturer warranty covering parts and labor.
  • Extended Warranty – Some retailers and credit cards offer additional protection.
  • SecondShop Guarantee – All new open-box appliances at SecondShop include a one-year warranty, so you’re covered if anything goes wrong.

If your appliance is under warranty, contact the manufacturer or retailer for a free or low-cost repair.

Step 3: Compare Repair vs. Replacement Costs

Not all appliance issues are worth repairing. Here’s how to decide:

  • Repair Costs Under 50% of Replacement Cost – If the repair cost is less than half the price of a new appliance, it’s usually worth fixing.
  • Older Appliances – If your appliance is nearing the end of its lifespan, replacing it with a discounted appliance may be a better investment.
  • Availability of Parts – Some brands, like KitchenAid appliances, have widely available parts, making repairs cheaper. Others may require expensive, hard-to-find components.
  • Energy Efficiency – Newer appliances are more energy-efficient, saving you money over time on electricity bills.
A homeowner unboxing a new open-box appliance in their kitchen. Discover discounted appliances with one-year warranties at SecondShop.

Step 4: Explore Replacement Options

If replacing your appliance is the smarter choice, you don’t have to pay full price. At SecondShop, you can find:
✔ New open-box appliances at discounted prices
✔ Fridges, washers, TVs, ovens, and ranges on sale year-round
✔ One-day shipping and appliance warranties for peace of mind
✔ Mix and match appliance bundles to save even more

Conclusion

If your appliance isn’t working, first troubleshoot the issue, check your warranty, and compare repair costs. If replacement makes more sense, SecondShop has you covered with discounted appliances, one-year warranties, and one-day shipping. Don’t waste money on costly repairs—shop smart and save today!

Ready to Upgrade?

Find the best appliance deals and appliances on sale, including fridges on sale near me, and buy now pay later appliances.

Back to blog